Maggie O'Farrell's 2020 novel Hamnet reimagines the domestic sorrow behind William Shakespeare's Hamlet: the death of eleven-year-old Hamnet in 1596 Stratford-upon-Avon, which O'Farrell imagines as caused by the bubonic plague. Shakespeare is never named directly in the text; instead, O'Farrell centres the narrative on his wife, Agnes (historically Anne Hathaway), an intuitive herbalist and healer, and explores the devastation that fractures their household. Prescribed for Leaving Certificate Higher Level 2027, Hamnet can be studied either on its own as a Single Text in Paper II Section A (60 marks) or as part of a three-text Comparative Study in Paper II Section B (70 marks) under the three prescribed modes: Theme or issue, Cultural Context, and General Vision and Viewpoint.
Paper II Architecture & Syllabus Requirements (2027)
Paper II at Higher Level lasts 3 hours 20 minutes and carries 200 marks: Section A (Single Text, 60 marks), Section B (Comparative Study, 70 marks), and Section C (Poetry, 70 marks). A sensible exam timing is roughly 55 minutes for Section A, 65 minutes for Section B, and 65 minutes for Section C, leaving 15 minutes to read and plan.
Pathway Options for Hamnet
- Section A (Single Text): You study the novel in close analytical detail. If you choose Hamnet here, the compulsory Higher Level Shakespeare requirement dictates that you must study a Shakespearean play (Macbeth or Othello) as one of your three texts in Section B.
- Section B (Comparative Study): You compare Hamnet with two other texts. Here, your Shakespeare requirement is satisfied either by studying Othello (the only Shakespeare play on the 2027 Single Text list) in Section A, or by including Macbeth or Othello as one of your comparative texts.
Section B Layout and Selection Rules
The syllabus prescribes three comparative modes for 2027: Theme or issue, Cultural Context, and General Vision and Viewpoint. However, the examination paper sets questions on only two of these three modes. You cannot predict which mode will be omitted, so you must prepare at least two modes thoroughly.
In Section B, each examined mode typically offers two choices, and you answer one question only:
- Option 1 (Single 70-mark question): You compare all three of your comparative texts together within a single sustained essay.
- Option 2 (Two-part question): Part (a) is worth 30 marks and examines one text alone. You must not compare in part (a). Part (b) is worth 40 marks and demands a sustained comparison of your two other texts on the same issue. You cannot reuse the text from part (a) in part (b).
Plot Arc & Narrative Architecture
O'Farrell structures the novel in two movements, using a lyrical present-tense voice that dissolves historical distance.
Part One: Converging Timelines
Part One alternates chapter by chapter between two temporal planes. The present strand unfolds across a stifling day in August 1596, tracking Hamnet as he searches an empty house and yard for an adult to help his suddenly feverish twin sister, Judith. The past strand begins with the courtship in the early 1580s and moves forward: a hurried marriage arranged once it is clear Agnes is pregnant, Susanna's birth, the twins' birth, and the husband's departure for London. This strand narrows until it converges with the 1596 timeline at the exact moment Judith falls ill. This structure creates intense dramatic irony, as every scene of youthful affection and domestic hope runs directly towards a catastrophe already underway.
The Flea Chapter
A celebrated chapter leaves human consciousness entirely to trace the journey of the pestilence westward: fleas carried aboard a trading ship by live monkeys, the infection passing to a cabin boy, then traveling through rags packed around a consignment of Murano glass beads shipped to London and finally to Stratford, where Judith handles the box. This sequence highlights human fragility and the terrifying arbitrariness of infection.
Part Two: The Anatomy of Mourning
Following Hamnet's death, the narrative moves in linear progression. Part Two explores the immediate aftermath: Agnes washing and laying out her son's body, the husband's retreat to London, the profound silence between the parents, and Agnes's eventual journey to the Globe Theatre.
Character Profiles: Central & Secondary Figures
O'Farrell rewrites the historical record from the inside, rescuing Anne Hathaway from centuries of patriarchal gossip by presenting her as Agnes: an autonomous, intuitive herbalist.
The Central Figures
- Agnes: Possesses a gift for reading people through touch, pressing the muscle between thumb and forefinger to sense character and future sorrow. Her herbal mastery gives her practical authority in the domestic realm, which makes her failure to cure Hamnet unbearable. Her foresight is genuine but limited: she foresaw two children beside her deathbed and assumed one would die in infancy, misreading the vision because she could not imagine surviving her son.
- The Husband (The Latin Tutor): Kept deliberately nameless throughout the novel. He is introduced as a sensitive young man physically abused and humiliated by his father, John Shakespeare. Agnes recognizes the creative genius within him and helps arrange his move to London. Rather than grieving openly in Stratford, he retreats to the stage, transforming private sorrow into art.
- Hamnet and Judith: Boy-and-girl twins, not identical, yet so alike in feature and manner that the town constantly confuses them. Hamnet lies down beside his sister because, with a child's logic, he believes that if they look alike death may take him instead of her. Judith survives, carrying heavy guilt in the quiet house.
The Secondary Household
- Susanna: The eldest daughter, sharp-tongued and impatient with her mother's prolonged mourning, illustrating how grief divides members of the same family.
- Bartholomew: Agnes's loyal, physically imposing brother who supports her against their family and escorts her safely on the long ride to London.
- John Shakespeare: The husband's father, a disgraced, volatile glover whose domestic violence drives his son toward the London playhouses.
- Mary Shakespeare: The husband's mother, who runs the bustling Henley Street kitchen, balancing practical domestic reliance on Agnes with resentment of her unusual habits.
- Eliza: The husband's sister, offering quiet female solidarity inside the noisy, crowded house.
- Joan: Agnes's harsh stepmother whose malicious village gossip brands Agnes as unnatural.
Aesthetic Style, Motifs, & Author's Methods
To succeed in the Single Text question, you must analyse how O'Farrell's stylistic choices shape meaning.
Sensory Detail and Present-Tense Narration
The prose relies on rich sensory imagery: the scent of boiled vinegar and crushed tansy, the sharp bite of falcon talons through thick leather, and the heavy physical reality of bubonic swellings. Telling the entire story in the present tense keeps the events unfolding in real time, giving Hamnet's panic and Agnes's despair an immediate, modern resonance.
Free Indirect Discourse
O'Farrell frequently uses free indirect discourse to slip smoothly into a character's interior thoughts while retaining third-person narration. When the text adopts Hamnet's childlike reasoning without quotation marks during his panicked search for an adult, the reader experiences the empty house through the boy's rising terror rather than detached description.
Key Motifs
- The Kestrel: Symbolises Agnes's wild independence, her instinctive link to the natural world, and her distance from town conventions.
- Leather and Gloves: Linked to John Shakespeare's craft, financial decline, domestic violence, and the claustrophobic atmosphere of Henley Street.
- The Withheld Name: By never naming William Shakespeare, O'Farrell defamiliarises a cultural icon, shifting attention away from London celebrity to the domestic world where women sustain life and lay out the dead.
The 2027 Prescribed Comparative Modes
Prepare your material so that it fits smoothly into the three modes prescribed for Higher Level 2027.
1. Theme or Issue
- The Nature of Grief: O'Farrell shows that loss can alienate grieving parents from one another. Agnes experiences grief through tactile absence and the physical soil of the grave, whereas her husband channels his agony into solitary writing in London.
- The Limits of Parental Care: Neither Agnes's natural remedies nor her intuitive foresight can resist arbitrary disease. Love offers no guarantee of biological survival.
- Art as Consolation: The production of Hamlet demonstrates how narrative can redeem private suffering, turning a lost child into an enduring stage presence.
2. Cultural Context
- Patriarchal Authority: Elizabethan society grants civic and financial dominion to men. John Shakespeare controls his adult sons, and marriages require economic settlements.
- Women's Unofficial Power: While denied legal authority, women hold responsibility over domestic life, herbal medicine, childbirth, and funeral preparation.
- Religion and Superstition: In an era lacking germ theory, the community relies on burning rosemary, sprinkling vinegar, and chalking crosses on infected doors to ward off contagion.
- Literacy and Social Standing: The Latin tutor's formal education contrasts with Agnes's practical herbal wisdom, marking a clear divide in social and gender status.
3. General Vision and Viewpoint
- The Opening: Hamnet alone in an empty house creates an immediate sense of human vulnerability.
- The Trajectory: The narrative balances dark realities (Hamnet's sudden death, the bleak funeral) against moments of vitality (the kestrel soaring, sibling tenderness, Bartholomew's loyalty).
- The Ending: Agnes discovers that the play Hamlet is not a cynical use of their private grief, but a profound memorial. Her husband takes on the role of the dead Ghost so their son can walk as the living Prince. The text delivers catharsis and qualified consolation: death remains permanent, but artistic remembrance survives.
High-Yield Key Moments & Textual Evidence
Ground every essay in specific, well-remembered textual moments. A short phrase woven directly into your sentence is far more effective than an isolated block quotation.
| Key Moment | Core Textual Evidence | Technique & Meaning | Exam Modes / Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Opening Search | "A boy is coming down a flight of stairs." | Present tense; establishes vulnerability and domestic isolation. | General Vision and Viewpoint; Narrative Technique |
| Courtship at Hewlands | Agnes pressing "the muscle between his thumb and forefinger". | Sensory tactile imagery; demonstrates Agnes's intuitive foresight. | Cultural Context; Character Analysis |
| The Pestilence Route | Fleas moving from live monkeys to Murano glass bead rags. | Macro-narrative perspective; highlights global trade and human fragility. | Cultural Context; Theme or issue |
| The Bedside Substitution | Hamnet lying beside Judith to fool death. | Child's perspective; demonstrates profound sibling devotion. | Theme or issue; Single Text Insights |
| Laying Out the Corpse | Agnes washing Hamnet's body herself with herbal water. | Domestic ritual; illustrates women's traditional care for the dead. | Cultural Context; The Nature of Grief |
| The Globe Performance | Hamnet and Hamlet were "in fact the same name". | Author's Note; theatrical transformation of personal loss into art. | General Vision and Viewpoint; Ending Analysis |
Key terms
- Theme or issue
- The prescribed comparative mode exploring a central human concern or philosophical question across three distinct texts.
- Cultural Context
- The prescribed comparative mode analysing the social codes, gender expectations, class structures, religious beliefs, and power dynamics of a text's world.
- General Vision and Viewpoint
- The prescribed comparative mode evaluating the overarching outlook on human life conveyed by the text as a whole, moving between despair, resilience, and hope.
- Clarity of Purpose
- The SEC marking criterion (30%) assessing how directly and consistently an essay answers the specific terms of the examination prompt.
- Coherence of Delivery
- The SEC marking criterion (30%) evaluating the organisation of ideas, logical transitions between paragraphs, and sustained structure of an argument.
- Efficiency of Language
- The SEC marking criterion (30%) assessing the precision, style, vocabulary, and analytical control of the candidate's writing.
- Accuracy of Mechanics
- The SEC marking criterion (10%) measuring spelling, punctuation, and grammatical correctness.
- dramatic irony
- A literary device where the reader understands the impending catastrophe while the characters remain unaware, heavily generated by the converging timelines in Part One.
- free indirect discourse
- A narrative technique presenting a character's internal thoughts and voice in third-person prose without formal dialogue tags or quotation marks.
- motif
- A recurring image, object, or phrase that reinforces central concerns, such as Agnes's kestrel or the glover's leather.
- catharsis
- The release and purging of emotional tension achieved at the Globe Theatre when private grief is transformed into shared dramatic art.
Check yourself
What are the three comparative modes prescribed for Leaving Certificate English Higher Level in 2027?
Theme or issue, Cultural Context, and General Vision and Viewpoint.
How many comparative modes appear on the Higher Level examination paper, and how many must you answer?
Two of the three prescribed modes appear on the examination paper; you answer on one mode only.
What critical historical fact does O'Farrell highlight in her Author's Note regarding the names Hamnet and Hamlet?
She notes that Hamnet and Hamlet were the exact same name, used interchangeably in Stratford parish records during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.
Name one moment that demonstrates the limits of Agnes's herbal power, and state what O'Farrell suggests through it.
Her natural remedies and predictive touch fail to cure Hamnet of the plague, demonstrating that human devotion and skill cannot overcome indifferent natural catastrophe.
What is the structural difference between Option 1 and Option 2 in Paper II Section B?
Option 1 is a single 70-mark question comparing three texts together; Option 2 divides into part (a) (30 marks, one text alone) and part (b) (40 marks, comparing the other two texts).
